ADVERTISEMENT

October 9, 2009

The concussion discussion continues.

All week, the hottest topic of conversation in college football was whether Florida quarterback Tim Tebow had sufficiently recovered from a concussion and would be able to play Saturday at fourth-ranked LSU.

Late Saturday, the word came that Tebow has received medical clearance to play.

But among the Tigers, talk has centered on a blow delivered to them. A year later, it still hurts.

"Last year, Florida really smacked us in the mouth," LSU tailback Charles Scott said. "We have to remember what it means to get smacked in our mouths."

LSU was 4-0 and coming off a bye week when it went to Gainesville last season. Tebow threw two touchdown passes and ran for another in a 51-21 victory that catapulted Florida toward its second national championship in three years. Florida led 17-0 before LSU got its initial first down, and it was the Tigers' worst loss in six seasons.

"Florida had a great team last year," LSU tight end Richard Dickson said. "No matter what we did, they had answers for us."

It took all week to get an answer to the most-asked question of the week: Will Tebow play?

He returned to practice this week, but wasn't involved in contact. Florida coach Urban Meyer said earlier Saturday if medical officials cleared the QB, he would see action.

"When you're healed, you're healed, whether it's next week or the week after," Meyer said earlier this week. "If you're not healed, you're not healed. It takes time."

Sophomore John Brantley will be ready to step in to one of the most hostile environments in college football if Tebow suffers a setback. LSU has won 32 consecutive Saturday-night home games.

A night game in Baton Rouge offers a difficult atmosphere, even for the most adept quarterback. Tebow threw an interception and completed fewer than half of his passing attempts in a 28-24 loss there in 2007.

Even with Tebow, the Gators' defense is the key to victory. That defense ranks first in the nation in total defense, 17th against the run, second against the pass and second in points allowed.

"Nobody's talking about that defense," LSU coach Les Miles said. "It's a veteran defense and it looks like it. Some of the guys who played on the national championship team three years ago are now second-team."

Last season, the Gators forced three LSU turnovers, including two interceptions off then-starter Jarrett Lee. One was returned for a touchdown by linebacker Brandon Spikes.

But sophomore quarterback Jordan Jefferson has been an upgrade for the Tigers. He has thrown for 920 yards, with seven touchdowns and just two interceptions. Receivers Terrance Toliver and Brandon LaFell have 23 receptions each, and Scott is coming off his best effort of the season with 95 rushing yards in a come-from-behind 20-13 win at Georgia last week.

That win has the Tigers making comparisons to their most recent championship season.

"It feels like 2007 again," LSU junior safety Chad Jones said. "Last year, we got behind real quick against Florida. Things didn't fall our way and it got out of hand. But I really believe that this year is like 2007."

Who gets the edge?

Florida rush offense vs. LSU rush defense:
Forget any notion about Urban Meyer's spread option being a finesse offense; the Gators are a power running team, thanks to a big and physical line, and the base play this season has been the read option. Florida leads the nation in rushing at 307.5 yards per game, but the level of the opponent rises greatly in this one. Tim Tebow's condition could make things interesting here. If he is OK, will Gators coaches go with their bread-and-butter play, or will they try to get the ball to their tailback trio in different ways? The Gators use a tailback-by-committee approach with Jeff Demps, Chris Rainey and Emmanuel Moody, but Tebow has served as the power back. If Tebow isn't back to full speed, how much of a hindrance will that be for the running game? LSU shut down Georgia's rushing attack last week, but the Tigers had trouble with Washington's and Mississippi State's running games earlier in the season. LSU's linebackers make a lot of tackles, but they still can be exploited by quick running backs. DT Drake Nevis has been active and productive up front.
Edge: Florida

Florida pass offense vs. LSU pass defense:
Florida's passing attack has been so-so. TE Aaron Hernandez probably is the most talented of the receivers; he has the speed to get down the seam and the power to run over defensive backs after he has made the catch. He was a big-time weapon on shovel passes last season, but that has been a rarely used play this season. WR Deonte Thompson is expected to play after being sidelined by a hamstring injury, and his presence gives the Gators a needed deep threat. WR Riley Cooper, Tebow's roommate, is a physical receiver who has been a home-run threat in the past but not so much this season. Florida backup QB John Brantley is a better pure passer than Tebow, he hasn't seen much time. LSU CB Patrick Peterson is a big-time cover corner with great size. FS Chad Jones covers a lot of ground and packs a wallop. LSU's pass rush has been a disappointment; the Tigers have just five sacks. DE Rahim Alem, who has two of the sacks, is the most dangerous pass rusher. LSU foes have completed less than 50 percent of their passes, with five TDs and eight picks.
Edge: LSU

LSU rush offense vs. Florida rush defense:
If LSU can run effectively, it will be in good shape. In Charles Scott, the Tigers have one of the most talented tailbacks in the league. LSU has not been as dominant on the ground as expected, averaging 135.4 yards per game with five rushing TDs. Keiland Williams is a solid backup tailback, and true freshman QB Russell Shepard is a threat in the Tigers' version of the "Wildcat" formation. Coach Les Miles has not been all that happy with his linemen and the Tigers' fullbacks have struggled, as well. Florida would get a boost if DT Lawrence Marsh, the Gators' best interior lineman against the run, is able to play; he has been bothered by a high ankle sprain and has missed three games. Florida has an active group of linebackers, headed by Brandon Spikes, and cornerbacks Janoris Jenkins and Joe Haden are active in run support.
Edge: Even

LSU pass offense vs. Florida pass defense:
This will be the eighth career start for sophomore QB Jordan Jefferson, who still is feeling his way a bit. He has good physical skills and can scramble. The Tigers might have the best receiving duo in the SEC in Brandon LaFell and Terrance Toliver; they have combined for 46 catches and seven TD receptions. TE Richard Dickson is a solid safety-valve receiver. LSU has allowed 13 sacks, including six last week to what had been a tepid Georgia pass rush. Florida has just seven sacks, a low number for a team with this many talented linemen. Look for a lot of Florida's "Joker" package - a 3-3-5 set - when LSU is in obvious passing downs. That enables defensive coordinator Charlie Strong to get good matchups for ends Carlos Dunlap and Jermaine Cunningham. Florida likes to blitz out of that set with a linebacker, safety or corner - and sometimes a combination thereof. Haden and Jenkins might be the best cornerback duo in the nation, and SS Ahmad Black always seems to be around the ball. Look for S Will Hill when the Gators play the nickel. The Gators have allowed one TD passes this season and opponents are completing less than 50 percent of their attempts.
Edge: Florida

Florida special teams vs. LSU special teams
Both have dangerous return men, Florida with Brandon James and LSU with Trindon Holliday. This season, James has been excellent on kick returns, awful on punt returns; Holliday has been good on punt returns but poor on kick returns. Both teams' coverage units have been superb, and Florida hasn't allowed any punt-return yardage this season. Florida P Chas Henry is better than LSU P Derek Helton. Neither kicker - Florida's Caleb Sturgis and LSU's Josh Jasper - has truly attempted a pressure kick. The Gators have blocked 27 kicks or punts, including a blocked punt for a TD against Kentucky, in Meyer's five seasons. LSU has had some issues with its deep snappers.
Edge: Florida

Coaching staffs
Both coaches have won national titles, with Meyer having won two of the past three. Look for a lot of in-game adjustments from two veteran defensive coordinators - Florida's Strong and LSU's John Chavis, who is in his first season with the Tigers after a long run with Tennessee. In four games at UT against Meyer and Florida, all losses, Chavis' defense gave up an average of 31.5 points per game. Miles is 2-2 against Meyer, winning both games in Baton Rouge.
Edge: Florida

X-factor:
This is easy - If Tebow plays well, Florida will be tough to beat. His presence would serve as a galvanizing force, and his leadership would be a huge boost during a night game in Death Valley. As for those who are tired of the Tebow hoopla, get ready for it to be taken to another level if in his first game after a concussion, he leads the top-ranked Gators to a win over fourth-ranked LSU on a Saturday night at Tiger Stadium.

Florida will win if:
If the Gators' defense stifles the run, Florida will be in excellent shape. The challenge for Florida's defense is to make the Tigers one-dimensional, and the Gators would feel good if Jefferson was forced to the air against their veteran secondary.

LSU will win if:
The Tigers need to make sure the home crowd stays in it for 60 minutes. LSU must avoid turnovers and force a few itself. A strong rushing attack would go a long way toward the Tigers springing the upset. LSU's secondary also can't allow many big plays.

EXPERT PICKS
Olin Buchanan: Florida 27, LSU 21
Tom Dienhart: Florida 27, LSU 24
David Fox: LSU 24, Florida 21
Mike Huguenin: Florida 20, LSU 14
Jason King: Florida 24, LSU 21
Steve Megargee: Florida 24, LSU 20
- Mike Huguenin

Olin Buchanan is the senior college football writer for Rivals.com. He can be reached at olin@rivals.com.




Rivals.com is your source for: College Football | Football Recruiting | College Basketball | Basketball Recruiting | College Baseball | High School | College Merchandise
Site-specific editorial/photos © Rivals.com. All rights reserved. This website is an unofficial and independently operated source of news and information not affiliated with any school or team.
About | Advertise with Us | Contact | Privacy Policy | About our Ads | Terms of Service | Copyright/IP policy